Following Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s controversial announcement about scrapping third-party fact-checkers and replacing them with X-like community notes, experts are concerned that these moderation changes will negatively impact European users. This comes despite the Digital Services Act (DSA) having come into force in February last year to protect Europeans from online misinformation and hate speech.
Another issue troubling Brussels is Elon Musk’s recent livestream with the leader of Germany’s far-right AfD party. He’s been publicly supporting the party, raising accusations of interference in German elections.
Studio Europa Maastricht sat down with Dr. Sally Wyatt, Professor of Digital Cultures at Maastricht University, to discuss the potential impact of Meta’s recent decisions on democratic processes in the U.S. and Europe, how regulatory differences—such as the absence of the DSA in the U.S.—will shape online spaces on both sides of the Atlantic, and whether the DSA can effectively challenge American big tech companies.
The interview was conducted before Musk’s livestream with AfD’s Alice Weidel.
Digital Services Act vs American big tech
While the rise of misinformation on social media platforms with millions of users is worrying, mainstream media in the U.S. still plays a significant role in its political culture, Wyatt says:
“I think it’s important to remember that mainstream media in the U.S. is still pretty powerful and influential, so it’s not like people only get their news from Facebook, Instagram, and X. The New York Times is still there. They’re constantly fact-checking Trump—though it doesn’t always have much effect—but there are both national and local news outlets that do a good job. There’s still an ideal of independent and balanced news in the United States.”
However, the pandemic and recent American elections showed that social media increasingly influences how news, including fake news, spreads. Europe is experiencing this phenomenon on a slightly smaller scale, Wyatt explains:
“A lot of people do get their information from social media, which I find concerning, especially younger people. It’s happening in Europe, too, but I think it’s less pronounced, partly because each country has its own national media and state-owned broadcasters. The balance between social media and traditional media is different than in the U.S. Regulations around news reporting are also stricter in Europe—both at national levels and the EU level—so there are more checks and balances. Yet social media is still very prominent here. We’ve seen this during the Brexit referendum, in recent Dutch elections, and now we’ll see what happens in Germany. So, there are definitely reasons for concern.”

Reflecting on whether the Digital Services Act could be an effective solution, Wyatt says it’s too early to tell:
“In theory, it sounds good, but in practice, we’ll have to see whether it will have any effect, particularly on big American tech companies. We’ve seen with some of the fines the EU has imposed on them that they just treat it as a cost of doing business. The same might happen with the Digital Services Act. We have to wait and see whether the DSA really has teeth and whether the Commission is prepared to take on big tech. There are signs that they are, but equally, Facebook, Google, and others don’t seem to view it as a major threat yet.”
“In theory, the Digital Services Act sounds good, but in practice, we’ll have to see whether it will have any effect, particularly on big American tech companies.”
Tech turning political
Despite these challenges, Wyatt believes that American tech companies are concerned about similar regulations being introduced in the U.S., which may explain Zuckerberg’s shift in approach:
“Obviously, Musk has been courting Trump for quite a while. Zuckerberg seems to have jumped on board, too. Both of them want to avoid similar regulations being introduced in the U.S., and Trump likely wants to give them free rein. It’s also in their interest for Trump to pressure the EU to scale back its regulatory efforts. While Trump hasn’t explicitly addressed this, given his recent comments about Canada, the Panama Canal, and Greenland, he’s clearly willing to use trade wars or tariffs to get what he wants. He’s already hinted at this regarding NATO contributions during his first presidency, and he’s more emboldened now.”

Wyatt highlights a fundamental issue: Europe lacks a strong tech industry to replace American platforms if necessary.
“In my view, the problem European countries face is that they don’t have a strong tech industry. China, Russia, and India all have equivalents to Facebook, Meta, and Microsoft. For various historic reasons, EU countries haven’t kept pace with tech development, so there’s currently no alternative.”
She suggests that European universities should take the lead in addressing this gap:
“It really irritates me that Dutch universities have essentially sold out to American big tech. Maastricht University has a contract with Microsoft; Groningen works with Google, and so on. Dutch universities, through SURF, could develop their own email servers. It’s not that hard. There’s a lot of talk about commitment to Open Science, but in practice, not much happens regarding infrastructure and software. Open Science should include these, and not just data sharing and open-access publishing. While it might be too much to expect an entire country to lead this effort, universities can set a good example.”
“In my view, the problem European countries face is that they don’t have a strong tech industry.”
Is moderation killing freedom of speech?
Wyatt also raises concerns about the erosion of responsible free expression:
“One of the things I worry about—and you see this in Zuckerberg’s recent justifications for getting rid of moderation and in everything Musk does—is the conflation of free expression with saying whatever you want. Freedom of expression, and academic freedom, isn’t about saying the first thing that comes into your head. Academic freedom requires thought, research, qualification of nuance and complexity, and grappling with uncertainty. Universities have an important role to play in fostering evidence-based argument.”
Instead of eliminating moderation, Wyatt believes big tech should invest in better technological solutions:
“Moderation is expensive, which is partly why people like Musk and Zuckerberg want to get rid of it. It’s also incredibly difficult work, often done by underpaid people in former British colonies where people speak English, and it can be traumatizing. To improve social media, we need moderation. Some argue it doesn’t work well, but instead of abandoning it, why not invest in better tech to improve it? If you believe in tech, use it for good.”
For Europe, Wyatt sees additional challenges due to its trade and competition regulations:
“When the EU was founded after World War II, the dream was a peaceful Europe. To maintain peace, you need a strong, independent press and respectful debate—not free-for-all, say-whatever-comes-to-mind discourse. However, the emphasis on free trade and competition laws has partially undermined these ideals. These laws contributed to the decline of national telecom and tech industries that once played a crucial role in innovation. Sometimes, you have to be careful what you wish for.”

Sally Wyatt is Professor of Digital Cultures in the Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences at Maastricht University. She has been doing research on the development and use of digital technologies since the mid-1980s. Together with Annika Richterich, she recently published an article called Feminist automation: Can bots have feminist politics?in the journal New Media & Society. (photo credits: Joey Roberts)
