The EU announced last week that it would double its tariffs on steel to 50 percent, bringing them in line with US levels. Studio Europa Maastricht spoke with Mark Sanders, Associate Professor of International Economics at Maastricht University about the latest developments surrounding the increase in steel tariffs.
What does this move mean for the European economy?
The standard economist response: it depends. The economic effects of this policy will come, if they come, through impacts on European steel prices and, to a much lesser degree, production volumes. The price effects are most important, as steel is an input in a wide range of industries. But the price effects are probably limited. That is because this tariff is not the only tariff. It was raised from 25 to 50 on all non-EU steel above 2013 import levels, not in response to the tariff of the US on EU steel but in response to the presumed dumping of Chinese steel on world markets that intensified after the US put up barriers to Chinese imports.
Already before the trade and tariff wars the Chinese have invested heavily in their steel industry and subsidised the sector, causing it to create a significant overcapacity. Now that the US market is no longer available to them, this overcapacity floods the non-US markets, most notably the EU. We need more steel for the defence industry, but not that much more and we do not want to depend on China for that supply. So Europe now sets a tariff on all non-EU steel to protect domestic production capacity.
We need more steel for the defence industry, but not that much more and we do not want to depend on China for that supply.
These tariffs may increase the price of steel in Europe. The stock market response showing significant drops in e.g. European car manufacturing companies suggest that the market is expecting that. But this will be partially offset by global steel price drops due to dumping. The tariff is on all steel from all countries to be in sign with WTO rules (non-discrimination) but the discrimination is then introduced by giving some, not others, a tariff free quota. I think the Commission aims for a more or less stable EU steel price, such that EU steel producers can still compete, at least in the EU. I read that one third of EU production capacity is currently idle due to cheap imports from mostly China, India and South Korea. We were not importing a lot of steel from the US in the first place, so the European Commission hopes to set up WTO-allowed non-discriminatory tariffs, using tariff free quota as an incentive for the US to lower its discriminatory tariffs on EU steel.

Photo: Joost Cu on Unsplash
I think this tariff will stabilize EU steel prices at a higher level than global market steel prices, but not much higher or lower than before the trade wars, such that the impacts on the steel using industries will be limited. We forego the cheap imported steel and pay more than we strictly would have had to, but the gain is that we help EU steel production survive this geopolitical turmoil.
This move by the EU may invite retaliation. From the Chinese because they are not going to just take this lying down and potentially from the Indians also.
But of course, this move by the EU may invite retaliation. From the Chinese because they are not going to just take this lying down and potentially from the Indians also. And it may have unintended side effects, for example on UK steel producers.
So in conclusion, in isolation, this tariff with quota does not create a lot of problems in Europe and may actually make sense. But I fear we are not in isolation. This is a move in a complex geopolitical game in which the countermoves of the US, China and India will matter a lot.
What does it imply for the EU’s future economic relations with the United States?
From what I read about this, the tariff plus quota move is explicitly intended to re-align the EU with the US. The US wants to protect its steel industry from cheap Chinese imports and global overcapacity as much as the EU wants this for its steel industry. The argument the EU is pitching is that the EU and US should do this together. If the US reduces EU tariffs or also gives the EU a tariff free quota, the net effect would indeed be a high tariff only on Chinese steel imports to both blocks.
It remains to be seen, however, if the Trump Whitehouse also interprets this move as extending a hand to join forces against China. After all, the EU has, to abide by WTO regulations, increased its tariff on all steel, including US steel. If that is seen as an unfair trade practice, the Trump Whitehouse (“The EU has been founded to screw over the United States”) may well retaliate. And of course the Chinese are correct in interpreting this as a move against their strategic interests. They have a lot of potentially very painful retaliation measures they can employ. The US quickly backed down from its trade war on China when export restrictions on critical raw materials form China were quietly suggested. I think Europe is as vulnerable to that threat as was the US, given the urgent need to push the energy transition and military ambitions.

Mark Sanders is Associate Professor of International Economics at Maastricht University. Mark’s research interests focuses on economic growth, energy transition, economic markets and policy.
