Dit expertinterview is alleen in het Engels.
The US midterm elections could have significant implications for the future of internet governance, digital rights and European technological autonomy. As the Trump administration adopts an increasingly authoritarian approach to free speech, internet governance and international cooperation, European policymakers face difficult choices about how to protect democratic values while managing their dependence on American technology.
Ahead of the US midterms, Studio Europa spoke with Mariëlle Wijermars, Associate Professor in Internet Governance at Maastricht University, about the consequences of the changing transatlantic relationship for European digital sovereignty.
Wijermars will be one of the speakers at our event “Europe’s response room: Navigating the perfect storm after the US Midterms” on November 3. Join the discussion by registering here.
Competitive autocracy
For Wijermars, the midterms are about more than the balance of power in Congress. They offer an opportunity to assess the resilience of American democracy and the extent to which the US administration’s changing political priorities are affecting Europe. She argues that Europeans need to take the implications of these developments seriously, including in the field of internet governance.
“Since Trump’s second presidency, we have to consider the US an authoritarian state. It is a competitive authoritarian state, meaning that elections still take place and that it remains possible for the opposition to win. But the playing field is tilted. The state can use its institutions to put pressure on the media, restrict media freedom, launch investigations into political opponents and intimidate them. Unfortunately, that is what we have been seeing since Trump returned to power.”
According to the expert, internet governance is one of the fields where it is particularly clear:
“In the past, the US was one of the key proponents of internet freedom and digital rights worldwide. The idea was that a global open internet could contribute to democratisation by empowering citizens in countries where governments restrict their freedoms. This was an important part of American foreign policy, including through the financing of civil society organisations, digital rights organisations and technologies that help people circumvent internet censorship. All of that has changed. The US has withdrawn support from initiatives that promote internet freedom and digital rights. One important example is the Freedom Online Coalition, a coalition of democratic states initiated largely by the US and the Netherlands to promote internet freedom and digital rights worldwide. The US has now withdrawn from that organisation as well.”
From AI Act to balancing act
There has also been a major shift in the way the US approaches disinformation. Wijermars points to a recent example – the controversy surrounding #Disinfo2026, a major European conference on disinformation held in Vilnius, Lithuania. Last week, the Trump administration pressured European and Canadian counterparts over the conference, after which the EU’s diplomatic service, Lithuania and Canada withdrew or reduced their official support. The dispute centred on a panel examining whether the US itself could pose a threat through foreign information manipulation and interference (FIMI).
“In the past, countering disinformation was one of the issues the US actively promoted. Now, the administration pushes back against the very idea of disinformation and accuses actors such as the European Commission of engaging in censorship. The US is no longer defending liberal values and civil liberties in the way it used to. Instead, it is actively promoting anti-democratic forces in Europe and interfering in our information space”.
“The US is actively promoting anti-democratic forces in Europe and interfering in our information space”
According to the expert, this case is a significant development in the EU-US relations that shouldn’t be overlooked:
“It shows the paradoxical position European actors find themselves in. On the one hand, they want to support a conference where civil society actors, researchers, and policymakers can openly discuss these issues. On the other hand, they need to maintain their relationship with the US and avoid angering the administration too much. They are forced to make choices that are not necessarily in line with their own priorities. But what concerns me most is what this means for open democratic debate in Europe. If we cannot have an open conversation about the authoritarian actions of the US, that is very concerning. A conference is precisely one of the places where researchers, civil society and policymakers should be able to come together to better understand these issues and discuss how to address them.”
Wijermars emphasises that without being able to even discuss harmful practices it is impossible to stop them:
“We should be able to talk about all the actors engaging in these activities. If the US is manipulating our information space, challenging liberal democratic values or shrinking the space for public debate, then we should be able to discuss that openly. This is a good example of the tensions that are emerging, and I think we should be much firmer. I was disappointed that the European actors did not take a stronger stand. They are not defending European values, such as freedom of academic inquiry, as firmly as I would have liked.”
Midterms as a test for democratic resilience
The midterm elections could provide an indication of how American voters perceive the damage to democratic institutions under Trump. However, Wijermars is cautious about expecting an electoral setback to translate into substantial changes in US policy towards Europe.
“It is a very important moment because we will see where US voters stand. We know that Trump’s popularity is low, but will that translate into votes? The elections could give us an indication of how resilient American democracy is. Do people recognise the damage that has been done to their institutions? Do they recognise that it is unacceptable for Trump to ban media outlets from the White House? And does that translate into actual votes?”
“If it does not, then I think we need to be wary. We also have to look at how the Trump administration responds to the results. Does it politicise them or try to undermine their credibility, as we have seen before? The way the administration handles the midterms will be an important indication of the direction in which the country is moving,” she continues.
According to the expert, the damage done would be hard to reverse:
“Will the administration consolidate its power further, or will democracy be able to bounce back? Some political scientists are hopeful that Trump’s unpopularity could mobilise the forces needed for a democratic recovery. But even if that happens, democracy will remain weakened. The damage to institutions and public trust is extensive, and the consequences for trust in the political system can be long-lasting.”
Wijermars does not, however, expect the election results to bring about a major shift in American policy. That means that European policymakers will need to consider how to strengthen their own position even if the political balance in Washington changes:
“I do not think the results will translate into massive policy changes, especially in foreign policy and technology. I also do not expect large technology entrepreneurs to suddenly change sides. Trump is still in office, and he makes it very clear that companies need to be in his camp and that there will be consequences if they do not comply. You can already see this tension in the way European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen talks about technology. When discussing social media, she argues that we cannot trust platforms to regulate themselves and that we need measures such as imposing age limits for social media use. But when discussing AI, she emphasises the need to collaborate with large technology companies to jointly establish safeguards and ensure that AI is used for good.”
“This is also a test of how firmly we stand behind the values we claim to protect”
Still Wijermars believes that Europe is not fully autonomous and can’t afford to breakup with the US:
“We understand that we need to maintain good relations with these companies and with the US. But this is also a test of how firmly we stand behind the values we claim to protect. We need to take concrete steps towards greater autonomy: investing in the European technology sector, innovation and science. At the same time, we remain dependent on American technology. The European Commission and the member states are walking a tightrope, trying to reduce those dependencies without damaging relationships they still need.”
New alliances for internet governance
For Wijermars, one of the most important consequences of the changing transatlantic relationship is the need for Europe to strengthen existing partnerships and build new ones. The US withdrawal from international initiatives supporting internet freedom means that European countries can no longer rely on the same coalition of democratic states to defend their interests.
“We need to continue looking for alternative alliances. In the past, we were broadly on the same side as the Americans. Of course, we had differences of opinion, including over what an global open internet should look like and who should be responsible for governing it. But we were generally in the same camp and could work together in international forums to push back against authoritarian influence.”
The EU needs to face the fact that the US is no longer its ally against authoritarian coalitions, led primarily by China and Russia that promote strengthening the power of the state at the expense of citizens’ freedoms, Wijermars explains:
“The US is now moving away from our coalition, and Europe needs to continue seeking new partners and expand its cooperation with other countries. That may mean working with countries we would not necessarily have considered obvious partners in the past. We can see this happening in the Freedom Online Coalition, whose membership has grown substantially over the years. But expanding the coalition also makes it more diverse, and that creates challenges.”
These differences matter particularly when it comes to defining the boundaries of online freedom. According to Wijermars, European countries themselves do not always agree on what should be permissible online, and these differences can become more pronounced when cooperation extends to countries with different cultural and political traditions:
“When we talk about online freedoms, cultural differences are very important. What people consider permissible to say online can vary significantly. Even the Netherlands and Germany have different views, and the differences can become much larger when we work with countries that have different cultural backgrounds. There are also differences in how much importance countries attach to civil liberties compared with socio-economic rights.”
Nevertheless, the EU needs to invest in these alliances, Wijermars warns:
“Otherwise, we risk losing influence, because the fundamental rules that govern the internet are established at the global level. Decisions about technical standards, for example, influence how we use technology and how the internet itself works. If Europe can no longer influence those discussions, while authoritarian coalitions become stronger, the consequences can seriously affect the internet we use. These are therefore extremely important debates. We are seeing alliances shift more broadly, and internet governance is no exception. Also in this domain, cooperation with partners such as Canada is becoming increasingly important.”
Divide and conquer
The changing political landscape also raises questions about foreign interference in elections. Russia has long sought to undermine Western unity, and the US midterms could provide another opportunity to exploit political divisions. But Wijermars believes the Kremlin’s broader strategic objectives are more important than any single election.
“I think Russia has two priorities at the moment. The first is to undermine support for Ukraine. The second is to divide and conquer, playing European allies off against one another. In that sense, anything that benefits the US administration in its current direction is also in Russia’s favour. But I am not sure the US needs any help from Russia.”
For Europe, the broader challenge remains the same: defending democratic values and maintaining influence over the digital environment while adapting to a transatlantic relationship that can no longer be taken for granted. The midterms may offer clues about the future direction of American politics, but Wijermars argues that European autonomy and cooperation with new partners will remain essential regardless of the outcome.

Dr Mariëlle Wijermars is Assistant Professor in Internet Governance. She conducts research on internet freedom and the human rights implications of internet policy and platform governance. Much of her work focuses on how authoritarian states, such as Russia, seek to shape and restrict the circulation of information and the role (inter)national platform companies play in implementing internet censorship.
